3 beginner traps

March 29, 2021 2 min read

3 beginner traps

If your plant doesn't survive in your aquarium, one reason might be that it is non aquatic in the first place. Or rather, it needs to grow emersed (i.e partially submerged) and cannot survive permanently under water.

These are often marsh plants that can be found growing near water bodies. They tolerate having their roots in water but their leaves need to grow above the water line. They are used to seasonal wet conditions but do not have the adaptations that true aquatic plants have that let them survive and grow underwater permanently.

Many of them are produced by the same farms that cultivate aquatic species. As these marsh plants are suitable for terrariums and bog gardens, farms do not necessarily discriminate between them. 

However many pet shops / aquarium shops indiscriminately sell these plants together with truly aquatic plants, which is a problem. In the top picture above, the non-aquatic Alternanthera sessilis is presented as an aquatic plant.

These marsh plants can survive for weeks submerged, but will eventually deteriorate. Their gradual decline in the aquarium also attracts algae as damaged and rotting plant tissue release sugars and proteins on which algae can feed.

Today we feature 3 popular examples that are attractive to beginners but are not suited for permanently submerged growth.

Alternanthera sessilis vs Ludwigia glandulosa

Trap 1: The irresistible purple

Above: Alternanthera sessilis (on the left) is a non-aquatic Alternanthera species that is commonly sold in pet shops and looks strikingly similar to Ludwigia glandulosa (right). Its attractive purple coloration makes it irresistible for hobbyists. 

It can be differentiated by its more rounded leaf tip compared to L. glandulosa. Ludwigia glandulosa has an alternate leaf arrangement, while A. sessilis has an opposite leaf arrangement. 

Hemigraphis repandavs Hygrophila pinnatifida

Trap 2: Dragon's Tongue

Above: Hemigraphis repanda (left) , also known as 'dragon's tongue', is another common non-aquatic. It has attractively shaped leaves with a purple underside. It looks very similar to the aquatic plant Hygrophila pinnatifida (right). It has shallower narrow lobs and is generally much thinner than Hygrophila pinnatifida.

Above: Hygrophila pinnatifida turns an attractive orange under a nitrate-limitation approach. Read more about this technique here.

Alternanthera ficoidea vs Staurogyne repens

Trap 3: Hooked Shrub

Above: Alternanthera ficoidea is another non-aquatic Alternanthera species. It looks very similar to Staurogyne repens. It has distinctively hooked shaped leaves, which is the easy way to identify it.

In summary:

  • When buying plants for your aquarium, beware of popular non-aquatic plants. They can last for weeks in a planted aquarium, but eventually deteriorate and trigger algae. 
  • 3 common non-aquatic plants are Alternanthera sessilis (with its irresistible purple leaves), Hemigraphis repanda ('dragon's tongue', the pinnatifida lookalike) and the Alternanthera ficoidea (the green shrub that looks like S. repens but has hooked leaves). 


Also in Hot Topics

What is wrong?
What is wrong?

August 20, 2022 2 min read

Aquarium plants not looking healthy, with many aerial roots and yellowing leaves. What is the problem?
Read More
Can APT Help?
Can APT Help?

May 06, 2022 3 min read

Superior nutrition can make a world of difference, but not in ways that we might think. Here we cover 3 scenarios where a little prep work is required for APT to do its magic.
Read More
Leaving for a holiday? How to prepare your tank
Leaving for a holiday? How to prepare your tank

April 14, 2022 6 min read

Leaving for a holiday? It can be frustrating to return to a 'crashed' tank. We cover the steps we can take to prepare our tanks to run smoothly when we are away.
Read More

the 2hr newsletter