Chlorine a concern?

May 03, 2021 2 min read

Chlorine a concern?

The use of Chlorine to treat water on an industrial scale dates back to the 1890s in Germany and the UK. Today, Chloramine is often added with Chlorine as it is more stable. While a few countries in Europe have moved to other methods, the vast majority of urban piped water systems across the world continues to use Chlorine and Chloramine to eliminate harmful pathogens.

Do I really need to use a dechlorinator? Is it one of those common but actually unnecessary items in the planted tank hobby?

Today most urban tap water contains between 0.2ppm (parts per million) and 2ppm of Chlorine and Chloramines. This is high enough to kill water-borne diseases, but low enough for human consumption. However this level is sufficient to harm fish and destroy the beneficial bacteria in an aquarium. For sensitive fish species, levels as low as 0.05ppm can be lethal.

A snapshot the general published levels of Chlorine / Chloramine in some cities:
Tokyo: 0.1 to 1ppm
Boston: 2ppm
London: 1ppm
Rome: 0.2ppm
Bangkok: 2ppm
Sydney: 1ppm
Singapore: 2.4ppm

But my friend doesn’t use a dechlorinator during his water changes, and the fish seem OK?

Chlorine dissipates by itself over time. A glass of water left standing will off gas most of its chlorine content in between 24 to 48 hours. So if your building receives water from a main water holding tank that has water left standing for a long time, it is possible for your tap water to have very low levels of chlorine by the time you turn it on, even if a high amount was injected during water treatment. Conversely, in residential households without holding tanks, where the pipes are constantly flowing, chlorine levels tend to be higher.

In Singapore for example, tap water usually has a chlorine level of around 2.5ppm. However, in office buildings where the water tank is large, the tap water that comes out can have near zero chlorine present due to the standing water off-gassing (say over a quiet weekend). But during weekdays, the chlorine levels rise due to the water tank being more constantly cleared.

In other words, chlorine levels can often vary.
Measuring zero today does not mean zero tomorrow.

What if my town is known for having low levels of Chlorine?

In areas where the level of chlorination is low, it is possible to do smaller water changes without dechlorinators without killing fish. It may still cause cumulative damage in the long run however.

In some cities, such as Tokyo, the targeted chlorine levels is low (around 1ppm) and tap comes out for most folks to have between 0.1 to 1ppm of chlorine. In such places, hobbyists find that they can do 20% water changes (without dechlorinator) without livestock being affected.

However, this is a dangerous practice.
If the water chlorine level spikes ( if the pipes are cleared faster than usual for that day) or if they do a larger water change and hit lethal levels, they lose livestock.

It is generally safer to use a dechlorinator if you reside in a country where water chlorination is used, as tap water chlorine levels may change over time.



Also in Hot Topics

What is wrong?
What is wrong?

August 20, 2022 2 min read

Aquarium plants not looking healthy, with many aerial roots and yellowing leaves. What is the problem?
Read More
Can APT Help?
Can APT Help?

May 06, 2022 3 min read

Superior nutrition can make a world of difference, but not in ways that we might think. Here we cover 3 scenarios where a little prep work is required for APT to do its magic.
Read More
Leaving for a holiday? How to prepare your tank
Leaving for a holiday? How to prepare your tank

April 14, 2022 6 min read

Leaving for a holiday? It can be frustrating to return to a 'crashed' tank. We cover the steps we can take to prepare our tanks to run smoothly when we are away.
Read More

the 2hr newsletter