Will copper from fertilizers hurt my shrimp or fish?

January 10, 2020 1 min read

Will copper from fertilizers hurt my shrimp or fish?

Shrimps and fertilizers

Shrimps are sensitive organisms generally, with CRS strains and higher grade shrimp being more sensitive than RCS & neocaridinas. Neocaridinas are generally hardier as well, and are a great choice for planted tanks.

Shrimps are sensitive to water quality and other stress factors (like predatory fish). Because of their delicate nature, many aquarists will end up killing them in their tanks - a number of folks will be dosing fertilizer at the same time and this results in wrong causation. 

Most commercial fertilizer do not have enough Copper (or any other harmful chemical) in them to affect livestock. I have also tested various commercial fertilizers on my cull shrimps in controlled overdose tests. Besides algicides (that come with shrimp warning labels) and Seachem Excel (not a fertilizer), every commercial fertilizer I tested failed to kill shrimps at 5-10X overdose rates. So shrimps are easy to kill, but not with fertilizer.

 I keep neocaridina shrimp in all of my planted tanks, and they breed like flies despite rich fertilization and CO2 levels.

When is copper a concern?

Some tap water sources have high copper levels (due to copper pipes usually). If your tap has high copper levels, RO is the only solution if you want to keep shrimps. Many commercial algicides may contain copper as well. Over zealous DIY fertilizer users may also hit lethal levels of copper, but it takes quite a bit of overdosing. 


Also in Livestock

Keeping dwarf shrimp in planted tanks
Keeping dwarf shrimp in planted tanks

June 08, 2022 7 min read

This article explains how to keep ornamental dwarf shrimp such as Neocaridina and Cardina species in a planted tank. It examines how to balance the needs of both planted tanks and shrimp.
Read More
Important water parameters for fish in planted tanks
Important water parameters for fish in planted tanks

March 06, 2022 3 min read

What water parameters to look out for when keeping fish, shrimp and other livestock?
Read More
Best schooling fishes for planted tanks
Best schooling fishes for planted tanks

February 03, 2020 2 min read

What types of fish are best for planted tanks? Which are good shoaling species? What should I avoid?
Read More

the 2hr newsletter